Business Plan and its evidentiary weight
The document from the Administrative Appeals Office (AAO) dated July 25, 2024, regards an appeal of a National Interest Waiver (NIW) petition. Here’s a summary of the key points:
Petitioner’s Claim
The petitioner sought an EB-2 classification with a National Interest Waiver (NIW), intending to own and operate a multimodal transportation company initially based in New York and later moved to Pennsylvania.
Director’s Decision
The Director of the Nebraska Service Center denied the petition, concluding that the petitioner did not meet the eligibility criteria for the NIW, particularly under the framework established by Matter of Dhanasar.
Material Change
The petitioner’s decision to change the business location from New York to Pennsylvania was seen as a material change to the petition. The Director determined this change was made to conform to the requirements, which is not allowed under USCIS rules.
Arguments on Appeal
- The petitioner argued that the Director misunderstood and misapplied the relevant legal standards, specifically the application of Matter of Katigbak.
- The petitioner claimed that the business plan is dynamic and subject to change based on various factors, and the change in location was in response to feedback on economically depressed areas.
AAO’s Decision
- The AAO upheld the Director’s decision, agreeing that the material change in the business location was significant and affected the eligibility under the Dhanasar framework.
- The AAO also found that the petitioner did not provide sufficient evidence to establish that the proposed business had substantial merit and national importance, that he was well-positioned to advance the endeavor, or that waiving the job offer requirement would benefit the United States.
Conclusion
The AAO dismissed the appeal, affirming that the petitioner did not meet the necessary requirements for the National Interest Waiver under the Dhanasar framework. This document outlines the detailed legal reasoning behind the denial of the petition, focusing on the issues of material change, the relevance of the business plan, and the application of the Dhanasar criteria.
related articles
case study
- Experienced Immigration Attorney for Indiana and Surrounding States Key Lessons from a National Interest Waiver Appeal
- Experienced Immigration Attorney in Indiana A Lesson in National Interest Waiver Case Dismissals
- Immigration Attorney in Indiana Insights on a National Interest Waiver Appeal for Forensic Accounting Services
- Immigration Attorney in Indiana National Interest Waiver (NIW) Denial Based on Exceptional Ability Without an Advanced Degree
- NIW Proposed Endeavor Medical Doctor National Importance
- NIW Success Story - Architect
- Why Was This Accountants NIW denied
- NIW Success Story: Pakistani Civil Engineer Paving the Way for Seismic Safety in the U.S.
- NIW Success Story: Mr. Lee – A Battery Recycling Innovator Advancing Renewable Energy in the U.S.